Surprises
Travis woke up Monday morning with Tim’s head still on his chest. He looked down to his blond hair and smiled. Travis felt Tim’s cock against his hip and his left leg draped across thighs. He felt like he needed a shower but he didn’t want to disturb Tim as he felt Tim’s breath on his chest. Travis thought about the decision they had to make today. He already knew he wanted to go with the plea deal, which left the final decision to Tim. He was concerned that Tim may want to push for a trial in order to punish Reverend Smith. Travis had looked on the internet to see the range of sentencing in the state and was shocked. There were some who got only probation with requirements for counseling, but there was also an egregious one who received a hundred and four years. He knew Reverend Smith wouldn’t get that amount and would probably get somewhere between five and twenty depending on how many other kids were involved and their ages. He assumed most of them had been the same age as he and Tim had been, but that made him wonder why the plea deal was so high. He heard talking and knew that Jeremy and Chris were already up. He hoped he and Tim could get to the bathroom unnoticed. He was sure the dried cum on his chest and possibly his hair would be obvious. He grinned and held back a chuckle as he recalled listening through the door as Jeremy had been fucking Chris. His cock stirred to life at the thought.
Travis felt Tim move a little, then he felt something wet drop on his chest. His first thought was that Tim might be drooling on him causing him to roll his eyes and then grin at the thought of teasing him about it. His mood changed to concern moments later when Tim said, “No. No!” Suddenly, Tim’s head sprang up from Travis’ chest and he turned to face him. Tears were running down his cheeks. Travis said, “Tim! It’s ok. It was just a nightmare. Reverend Smith again?” Travis reached up and wiped the tears from Tim’s face. Tim said, “I know what my decision has to be now.” Travis asked, “Was it the nightmare?” Tim nodded, “I was in the courtroom and there was a kid on the stand crying. He was describing what was done to him and this guy kept asking him for more detail. The kid was crying and sobbing so much, I could barely understand what he was saying, but the guy didn’t seem to care.” Travis said, “That sounds like a defense lawyer.” Tim nodded, “I can’t make those other kids go through that, Travis.” Tim started sobbing as tears continued to pour down his cheeks. Travis sat up and hugged him tightly, “It’s ok, Tim. We’re going to get through this. Ten years is still a long time.” After hugging each other for a while, Tim asked, “So, do you agree with me, that we let him take the plea agreement?” Travis replied, “Yes. Let’s put this behind us, but I think we both should insist on making a statement at his sentencing. I think it would help to put this behind us.”
As Tim and Travis emerged from Carl’s bedroom, Chris and Jeremy both said, “Good morning!”. Their faces went from smiles to concern. Jeremy asked, “Are you ok, Tim?” Tim nodded but remained silent. Chris asked him, “What’s wrong, Tim. It’s obvious you’ve been crying. It’s ok, but please tell us what happened. Another nightmare?” Tim nodded again, but this time explained what his nightmare was about. Then Travis said, “We’ve both decided to agree to the plea deal. We don’t want any of those kids to have to go through telling their stories to a courtroom full of people.” Chris said, “That would include both of you, too.” Tim then spoke, “We want to make a statement at his sentencing.” Jeremy said, “I think that’s a good idea, more for your own good than anything it might do for him. It might give you some closure.”
After breakfast, they headed to the police station. They sat in a room for a while before a detective and a lawyer from the DA’s office came in. They asked if Tim and Travis had made a decision. Travis said, “We agree to let him plead guilty.” The Assistant DA asked Tim, “Is that your decision as well, Mr. Houston?” Tim raised his head and said, “Yes sir, it is. Can we make a statement at his sentencing?” The Assistant DA said, “I’ll speak with the judge, but I’m sure he’ll allow that.” Just as they were shaking hands with the detective and Assistant DA, two officers came through a door, escorting the Reverend Smith in cuffs and an orange prison jumpsuit. Reverend Smith glanced over and saw them through the window of the room they were in. Tim looked away from him, but Travis, Jeremy, and Chris stared at him with steely eyes and anger on their faces causing him to turn away. Travis said, “He’s just a coward.” That caused Tim to look back up, but they were already going through another door. The detective said, “They’re taking him to sign the plea agreement. Sorry that they paraded him through like that, but maybe seeing you two will make sure he doesn’t back out.” The Assistant DA said, “The plea deal is pretty stiff, being ten years, but two of the boys he’s been accused of raping were only fourteen at the time. You did a brave thing, Tim. You saved those boys from a lot of future suffering, and most certainly saved some others in the future from the same fate.” Tim gave him a half smile, then he suddenly looked like he just realized what the Assistant DA said, “When you said raping, did you mean..?” The Assistant DA nodded, then said, “Yes. I don’t mean to belittle your ordeal as it must have been an awful experience, but he had allegedly anally raped several of them numerous times.” A tear ran down Tim’s cheek, and Travis said, “That monster deserves to rot in prison!” The Assistant DA said, “Yes, he does, but ten years is a pretty stiff sentence for a first offense and there’s no guarantee that he’d get more from a jury trial.” Tim said, “I don’t want to have any of his victims go through that.” The Assistant DA nodded, “Yeah, the defense lawyers can be very brutal on cross examination. It’s their job though. I’m sure they don’t sleep well after days like that.” Travis said, “I could never be a defense lawyer in a case like that.” Tim asked, “Why did you say allegedly? Isn’t it obvious what he did to them?” There was some anger in Tim’s voice. The Assistant DA said, “Yes, it is obvious to me, but until the court finds him guilty, either by jury trial or plea deal, he is innocent until proven guilty. As a prosecutor, I can accuse him of crimes and present witnesses to prove my case, but until a jury returns a verdict of guilty, or in this case, until he signs the plea agreement, he’s not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. I apologize for how I phrased it has upset you. I’m sure you’re still going through some trauma from what he did to you. Again, I think you were a brave man to do what you did and commend your friends’ bravery as well for having your back. I hope you get all the help you need to put this horror behind you, both of you.” Travis said, “Thank you. You’re right about Tim’s bravery. I am so proud of him for what he did.” Jeremy added, “We’re all proud of him even though we tried to talk him out of it.” The detective said, “You should be proud of yourselves as well.” Tim said, “They’re my heroes. I’m so glad they took me in after what I did.” Travis’ mouth dropped open when he realized what Tim had just said. The detective raised an eyebrow, but he didn’t press Tim for an explanation. Tim suddenly realized what he had said and hoped no one would ask for an explanation. Jeremy was ready to jump in if either the Assistant DA or detective asked. Neither did.
On the way back, Tim said, “I’m glad that’s over with.” Travis said, “I about shit my pants when you said, ‘after what I did’, in front of them.” Chris added from the front seat, “I know, right?” Jeremy glanced in the rear-view mirror at Tim, and said, “Don’t worry, Tim. If they asked about what you meant, I had your back.” Tim smiled sheepishly, “When I realized what I had just said, I froze. I’m glad they didn’t ask.” After dropping Tim and Travis off at the house, Jeremy and Chris headed to the campus for afternoon classes.
As they walked into the house, Tim said, “I haven’t been alone in this house since the time I came in through a window.” Travis asked, “What, am I a nobody?” Tim turned to explain, “I meant being in the house without one of the guys who live here or Chris.”, then he realized Travis was grinning, knowing what he had meant. As the door latch clicked behind Travis, Tim moved in for a kiss. Soon, Travis was inching Tim toward the living room as they continued to kiss and run their hands all over each other. Their hard cocks were grinding together through their jeans as they made it to the sofa. As the back of Tim’s legs met the sofa, he immediately sat down and began opening Travis’ jeans. He yanked them down around his ankles. Travis’ red Calvin Klein briefs were stretched tightly around his engorged cock. Tim leaned in and swiped the tip of his tongue across the wet spot forming at the tip of Travis’ cock. He looked up at Travis with a smile on his face as he slid the briefs down, receiving a slap across his cheek from Travis’ rigid member. Tim wasted no time taking the juicy, precum-leaking cock into his mouth. He savored the flavor of Travis’ precum as well as the taste and texture of Travis’ stiff cock. Travis’ hands were on Tim’s head as his fingers ran through Tim’s blond curls, while Tim’s hands were on Travis’ butt cheeks, rubbing and squeezing them. When Travis felt his balls churning, getting ready to evacuate their sperm, he pushed Tim off, “I don’t want to cum yet.” Tim smiled at him and then Travis pulled him up from the sofa and quickly took his place. As Travis began opening Tim’s jeans, Tim reached down and pulled at Travis’ shirt. Once Tim’s jeans were down around his ankles, they began undressing each other completely. Travis then took Tim’s cock and began licking it like an all-day sucker, making sure to lap up the precum when he reached the tip. Tim was almost cooing as Travis’ tongue worked its magic. Travis then moved to lick Tim’s balls before taking each one into his mouth, sucking and licking them. After he released Tim’s balls, he began swirling his tongue around the head of his cock, teasing him for a bit before taking it into his mouth. Tim joked, “Talk about a cock tease.” Travis almost choked on Tim’s cock from the remark. Travis then went to work, slurping and bobbing on Tim’s cock like a starved infant on his momma’s tit. Tim soon had to push him off, “Let’s get in a sixty-nine.” Travis swung onto his back and Tim climbed over him. Soon they were slurping down each other’s cocks like kids with freeze pops on a hundred-degree day. They both had their hands on each other’s butt cheeks. Travis’s legs slowly parted as one of Tim’s fingers found its mark. Travis moaned loudly as the finger penetrated him. Tim was noticing Travis’ fingers getting closer to his own rose bud, but instead of freaking out, after having cum the last time Travis barely touched it, he nervously allowed it. Travis was now moaning more loudly signaling he was soon about to spill his seed. Tim felt Travis’ fingers brush over his pucker, causing another flood of precum from Tim’s cock as well as a moan of pleasure on Travis’ cock. Travis took it as permission to continue. Tim felt the fingers brush across his hole again and he felt his balls readying to pump his seed. He moaned even louder, and Travis pressed his middle finger against Tim’s pucker and began swirling it around the tight ring. Tim groaned and Travis felt Tim’s cock swell slightly and then pulse, firing a rope of cum into his mouth followed by more as Travis began swallowing. As Tim was caught up in his moment of euphoria, he felt Travis’ anal muscles tighten around his fingers, followed by wad after wad of cum flooding his mouth. He swallowed hungrily as the slightly salty, slightly sweet swimmers filled his mouth. As their cum flow slowly ebbed to a dribble, Tim swirled his tongue around Travis’ cock, cleaning every drop of cum. He kept his lips tight as he slowly pulled off Travis’ still stiff rod, and then slowly pulled his own cock from Travis’ tightly closed lips. Tim then laid down onto Travis as they kissed and shared what was left of the cum in their mouths. As they kissed, Travis began grinding his crotch against Tim’s. Tim chuckled against Travis’ mouth feeling his hard, wet cock sliding against his own. Travis was still horny, he was encouraged that Tim had allowed him to play at his tight hole. The possibility of Tim eventually letting Travis fuck him excited him. He broke the kiss long enough to say, “Fuck me, Tim.” Tim lifted his face from Travis’ and smiled, “You’re turning into a sex fiend. Let me get some lube and a towel.” Tim jumped up from the sofa and practically ran into Carl’s room, then to the bathroom for a towel. When he returned, Travis had a huge grin on his face. Tim smiled and asked, “What?” Travis replied, “You called me a sex fiend and then rushed to get back to fuck me, and I’m sure that string of liquid hanging from the tip of your dick didn’t come from that tube in your hand.” Tim blushed slightly, “I never said I wasn’t a sex fiend myself. Now get those legs up.” Travis grabbed the back of his knees and pulled his legs up as Tim placed the towel beneath him. After Tim applied some lube to Travis’ hole, he applied some to his drooling cock. He then climbed between Travis’ legs and guided his cock to Travis’ tight rosebud. He slowly penetrated Travis’ love canal as Travis sighed contentedly. He was soon pressed tightly against Travis and bent down for a kiss, before he slowly tugged back outward and then pushed back in. Tim gradually sped up his strokes as Travis panted with his mouth open and his eyes fixed on Tim’s. Travis begged Tim to fuck him harder, deeper and faster. They fucked for quite a while before Tim slowly lowered himself down onto Travis with his hips frantically moving, pistoning his cock inside Travis. Travis’ cock was pressed between them as Tim’s abs slid across it while he fucked Travis. Suddenly, Travis cried out, “Fuck! Fuck me, Tim! I’m cumming!” Tim felt Travis’ cock pulsing beneath him as his cum blasted between them. Tim then cried out, “I’m gonna cum!” Travis said, “Cum inside me! Give me your cum, Tim!” Tim grunted and shoved in deep as he painted Travis’ love canal with his swimmers. As the last of his seed dribbled from his cock, Tim collapsed down onto Travis as his chest heaved. Travis wrapped his arms around Tim in a tight embrace as Tim’s head lay on his shoulder. They slowly caught their breath but remained in their tight embrace. They kissed for a few minutes and then just laid in each other’s arms with Travis’ cum wedged between them and Tim’s cock still inside Travis. Satiated and tired from their stressful day, they both drifted off to sleep.
As Jeremy and Chris finished their last classes before Christmas break, they got into Jeremy’s car. Chris asked, “Are you sure it will be ok for me to stay at your parents’, especially after you break the news to them?” Jeremy said, “I’m sure. They’re too polite to kick a guest out of their home. I’m more concerned they might be disappointed in me. They’ve never made a disparaging remark about a gay person, but finding out their own son is bisexual might be different.” Chris said, “I hope they handle it like my parents did, and not like Tim’s dad.” Jeremy grinned, “I’m sure they’d never be that extreme.”
As Jeremy and Chris entered the house, Chris said, “I wonder where Tim and Travis are. The house is quiet.” Jeremy turned to Chris quickly and had his finger up to his lips, indicating for Chris to be quiet. Chris gave him a questioning look but followed Jeremy in silence. As Jeremy stepped aside, Chris saw why he’d been silenced; on the sofa lay two naked guys, one on top of the other. It was hard to tell if Tim’s cock was sill inside Travis, but it was obvious it had been by the position of Tim’s legs. Jeremy and Chris smiled at each other as they looked on. Chris whispered to Jeremy, “Don’t wake them up. They look hot like this.” Jeremy smiled and whispered back, “They look adorable. Two twinks in love. Let’s enjoy the view while it lasts.” Suddenly, the door opened, and Elijah came in saying, “My last class…” He suddenly stopped as both Jeremy and Chris were signaling for him to be quiet. He wrinkled his eyebrows in a questioning look as he walked forward. Then he saw them and his jaw dropped. Slowly, he began to grin in amusement, then whispered, “Guess we’re getting some payback for when Tim walked in on us.” Jeremy and Chris both grinned. Tim stirred a little. His head was on Travis’ left shoulder, facing toward the back of the sofa. Tim was facing slightly toward Tim’s head, with his nose in his curly blond hair. Elijah joined Jeremy and Chris on the other side of the room. Travis’ arm moved on Tim’s back and then his eyes fluttered open. His hand moved up as he ran his fingers through Tim’s soft blond hair. Tim stirred and Travis said, “Hey, Tim. We should get up and get in the shower before Chris and Jeremy get back. We fell asleep.” Tim stirred and turned his head slightly so he could kiss Travis, then he said, “How long were we asleep as he rolled toward the back of the sofa, saying, “Your cum has us glued together. Oh, shit!” Tim was now looking at three sets of eyes on them and realized they were both naked and hard. He quickly rolled back on top of Travis to hide their hard cocks. Elijah joked, “Quite the contrast of blond and dark brown pubic hair. So, the cum between you is Travis’. That must mean..” Tim turned away, embarrassed, “Shut up, Elijah.” Travis said, “Oh my God. This is so embarrassing. Somebody please shoot me and put me out of my misery.” Chris said, “Guess this is payback for when you watched us going at it and left a mess on the floor, Tim.” Travis started laughing, “They’re right, Tim, but I wasn’t involved in that.” Tim then asked, “Could one of you get us a towel?” Elijah asked, “Why? We already saw your hard junk and your butt is hanging out right now.” Tim rolled his eyes and said, “Fine. Chris has already seen me naked and hard already.” Tim rolled off Travis and sat in front of his legs with his stiff cock protruding up from his blond pubic bush. Travis yelled, “What the fuck, Tim?” He covered his own hardness the best he could with his hands, revealing the dried cum on his abs and chest. Tim saw this and began to laugh. Travis said, “This isn’t funny, Tim, it’s embarrassing.” Tim said, “What’s funny is that you covered your junk but now your dried cum is on full display.” Travis then realized it and said, “Thanks for pointing it out to everyone, fucker.” Jeremy then said, “Don’t feel embarrassed. I thought you two looked pretty cute lying there on the sofa when we came in. You do look pretty hot. You may not have our muscle, but you’re both pretty toned, not a bit of fat on either of you.” Travis blushed at the complement, “You’re just saying that to make us feel better.” Elijah said, “I wouldn’t kick either one of you out of my bed.” Jeremy then suggested, “Why don’t you two get cleaned up while we get dinner started?” Tim said to Travis, “Yeah, let’s get in the shower.” He got up and then took Travis’ hand and pulled him up. By now, their cocks had softened and were hanging over their balls. Elijah gave a cat whistle as they walked toward the bathroom. Tim turned back grinning.
As they stepped into the shower, Tim giggled, “I wasn’t planning on us falling asleep.” Travis said, “You think? That was embarrassing. You think Elijah meant what he said about not kicking us out of his bed?” As Tim washed Travis’ back, he said, “You are really cute, Travis.” Travis laughed and said, “Look who’s talking, blond angel. Fuck, everywhere I look in this house is a hot guy!” Tim smiled and said, “Including when you look in the mirror.” Travis blushed and asked, “You really think I’m cute?” Tim said, “I already told you I had a crush on you from the first time I met you in choir.” Travis then asked, “Could I ask you something, Tim? I don’t want you to take it the wrong way.” Tim said, “Ask away.” Travis asked, “If you had the chance to have sex with one of them, would you?” Tim turned Travis toward him and gave him a kiss, then looked him in the eye and said, “I already told you I had oral sex with one of them. I just didn’t tell you who it was, and before I say anything else about it, know this; you are my boyfriend. You have my heart. I wouldn’t have sex with anyone else from now on if that’s what you want.” Travis smiled, “I think you partially answered my question. Travis gave Tim a brief kiss and said, “You have my heart, too. What if I was ok with us having sex with others as long as we both agree to it?” Tim said, “Then I would be open to it. I had oral sex with Chris. The three of them have an open relationship. They wear condoms when they have anal sex with others. They’re all on Prep also. The way Chris explained it was that having sex with people other than your boyfriend or boyfriends in his case is an enjoyable experience, but it’s just sex. When it’s with your boyfriend, it’s usually about making love. Do you understand what I’m saying?” Travis nodded, “I do. If you want, we could have a relationship like that as long as we’re honest about it. I trust you, but for now, let’s only have sex with others when we’re together.” Tim smiled and said, “Agreed”, then he started grinning. Travis asked, “What are you grinning at?” Tim said, “I was just picturing you getting fucked by Chris while Elijah has his cock down your throat.” Travis laughed and said, “I might like that, but I think I wouldn’t mind fucking any of their hot butts either.” Tim said, “You got that right, but let’s agree on one thing.” Travis asked, “What’s that?” Tim said, “You haven’t fucked anyone yet, right?” Travis nodded. Tim continued, “I know I panic when someone presses their cock up against me, but I’m trying to get over it. When I do, I want you to be my first, and I want to be your first. Can you agree to that.” Travis nodded, smiled, and said, “I’d like that very much. You were my first and only. The least I can do is be your first, and I promise you’ll be the first person I will stick my dick in.” They sealed the deal with a long kiss and then finished washing each other.
Almost as soon as they emerged from Carl’s bedroom, Tim received a call. As he picked it up and looked at it, he said, “It’s the DA’s office. I wonder what they want?” He answered the call, “This is Tim Houston. Can I help you?” Yes. Yes, I would like to do that. When? That soon? Oh. Ok. I’m sure I can be there. Thanks. Bye.” Everyone’s eyes were on Tim. He said, “They said the judge is retiring at the end of the year and wants to clear his docket as much as possible before he does. Since Reverend Smith signed the plea deal, he wants to sentence him the day after Christmas. They said I could make a statement then if I wanted to. I told them I’d be there.” Just then Travis’ phone received a call from the DA’s office asking him the same thing. He told them he would make a short statement if he could follow Tim, and they said that it would be fine. Jeremy and Chris received a call as well telling them about the sentencing and that they could attend if they wished. They let them know they’d be out of town. Elijah said, “That was fast. I wonder when he’ll have to report?” Tim said, “They didn’t say. I guess that will be up to the judge.”
As they ate dinner, Jeremy went over some of the things he wanted Tim to take care of while they were gone, mostly things like keeping the house clean, watering the few plants that they had and shoveling any snow they might get. Chris surprised Travis and Tim by handing Travis the keys to his jeep, “You can use my jeep to get to the courthouse and any other NECESSARY errands.” Tim asked, “If it snows, can we use it to go over to the Reynolds to shovel their walks?” Jeremy, Chris, and Elijah all smiled, and Chris said, “Sure, but be very careful driving in the snow, and use four-wheel-drive.” Elijah rolled his eyes and said, “You sound like a concerned parent.” Jeremy grinned at the remark and Elijah got the side eye from Chris. Tim then asked, “If I get my learner’s permit, will you guys teach me how to drive?” Jeremy and Chris both said, “Sure.” Elijah said, “You’re braver than I am”, as he grinned at Tim.
After cleaning up from dinner, they took turns playing Call of Duty and then a game of Jenga so everyone could play together. While playing, Elijah said, “Too bad Josh isn’t here with his Twister game.” Travis said, “I haven’t played that game since I was a kid.” Tim admitted, “I’ve never played it.” Jeremy and Chris looked to each other, both knowing the other felt sad for Tim. After Jenga, Elijah asked Jeremy to get out the deck of cards. Chris asked, “What are we playing?” Tim said, “How about Gin.” Travis said, “With five people, the draw pile won’t be very big.” Elijah suggested, “Poker.” Tim said, “Travis and I don’t have any money.” Elijah grinned mischievously, “We could play strip poker.” Chris looked at Elijah and asked, “Seriously?” Tim blushed as he thought about the idea of undressing in front of the three older guys. Travis blushed a little too, but he was thinking of the three older guys undressing in front of him. His cock twitched to life at the idea. He looked to Tim and grinned. Tim saw the look in Travis’ eye and realized what he must be thinking and soon had a grin on his face. Elijah replied to Chris, “It’s not like we haven’t seen everyone here naked before. The only one who hasn’t seen the three of us naked is Travis. What do you think, Travis?” Travis turned bright red. He hadn’t planned on being put on the spot like that. Should he say they should or shouldn’t play. He decided to play it safe, “It doesn’t really matter to me. Whatever everyone else wants to do.” Elijah then asked Tim what he thought, “What do you say, Tim?” I um, guess we could.” Jeremy was returning from getting them some drinks, and as he was handing them out, asked, “We could, what?” Chris replied, “Elijah wants to play strip poker.” Jeremy raised an eyebrow, “I heard Tim’s reply. What does everyone else think”, he asked as he looked at Travis. Elijah said, “Travis said it didn’t matter to him.” Jeremy asked Travis, “Is that what you said?” Travis was trying to picture Jeremy naked. He'd seen him in briefs quite a few times, but never naked. The thought of it made his cock begin to stiffen even more. Then he thought about everyone seeing him hard again and began to grow nervous. His brain was going a hundred miles an hour deciding on whether seeing him hard again was worth the risk against finally seeing the three of them naked. He really wanted to see their perfect but different asses. He also wanted to see their cocks, and hoped they would be as hard as he knew his would be. Jeremy waved a hand in front of Travis’ face, “Hello. Travis? Is anyone home?” Travis suddenly returned from being inside his own head and blurted out, “Yes! Um, I mean, I’ll play.” Chris said, “I guess we’re playing strip poker then.” Elijah looked overjoyed. He kind of felt like a slightly older brother to Tim and Travis, but he was also becoming a gay horndog since he came to realize he loved sex with other guys. This wasn’t going to be sex, but it would get him plenty horny for when they went to bed later.
They made sure everyone had the same amount of clothing. If someone had on too few, they would give them a sock from Jeremy’s dresser to throw on the pile. They agreed on six articles of clothing, shoes, socks, shirt, T-shirt or undershirt, pants, and underwear. Everyone was wearing those, but Travis had to remove the sweatshirt he had on over his shirt. They played Five-Card Draw. After ten hands, Travis had not yet lost one. Elijah was left with only his pants and underwear on. Chris had just removed his shirt, and Jeremy had only lost his shoes and socks. Tim, who had lost only his shoes so far, looked at Elijah, and asked with a smile, “What does the loser have to do?” Travis asked, “What does the winner get?” Jeremy said, “You should have asked that before we started. Elijah’s already half naked.” Chris grinned and said, “I think that’s why they’re asking now.” Elijah grinned and said, "I’m down with whatever we decide. What do you think, Travis?” Travis shrugged, “I don’t think it would be fair for me to say since I’m winning at the moment.” Tim figured Elijah was most likely to lose, and since he’d only lost one hand, suggested, “How ‘bout the loser sucks the winner’s dick.” Jeremy gave Tim a surprised look, “You do realize the game isn’t over yet and it could be you doing the sucking, right?” Tim said, “I’ll take my chances. After you found me and Travis on the sofa today with his cum all over us, I don’t think I could be more embarrassed.” Chris smiled, “You guys looked pretty hot like that. You’re lucky we didn’t start licking you clean when you rolled off him.” Everyone laughed and Travis’ eyes were on Chris’ cute dimples. Chris then suggested, “What if the loser gets a facial from the winner?” Elijah said, “That sounds fire to me.” They resumed the game, and Travis lost the next hand, followed by Chris. Tim and Travis lost the next two. Jeremy and Travis lost the following two. On the next hand, Elijah lost his pants, leaving him in a pair of orange and black American Eagle briefs with an obvious hardon trying to escape. Travis and Tim were both hard as steel in anticipation of seeing it revealed. Travis lost the next hand, followed by Tim leaving Tim tied for the lead with Jeremy. Tim then lost the next one as well, leaving Jeremy in the lead in his undershirt. The rest were bare from the waist up. Travis lost once more, and everyone watched as he slid out of his jeans. His stiff cock popped out of the fly momentarily before he wrestled it back inside which got a laugh from everyone. Travis was embarrassed, but he was now worried he might lose. The prospect both frightened him and made his dick throb at the thought. Jeremy lost the next two hands, making the game very close. They all watched Jeremy slide out of his jeans. Tim and Travis both stared at the muscular buns wrapped in bright red CK briefs. Chris lost the next hand, leaving only Tim with his jeans still on. Chris’ muscular apple buns filled out his baby blue Jockey briefs very well. Chris yelled, “Fuck!”, as he lost the next hand and his briefs. He now waited to see whose cock he would be sucking. Travis already had a wet spot forming in his boxers even though he kept trying to reposition his stiff rod. Elijah was the next one to be naked. He made a point to do a strip tease for Tim and Travis. Tim lost his jeans next. The navy blue Jockey briefs that Carl had bought him already had a large wet spot spreading. He lost the next hand as well, leaving it down to Jeremy and Travis. Tim’s hard cock sprang straight out as he lowered his briefs. Travis didn’t care which of them won at this point. Watching Chris suck Jeremy would be pretty hot. Having Chris’ lips around his cock would be hot as well, but he’d have an audience and wasn’t sure how he felt about that. He won! Travis watched as Jeremy slid out of his tight briefs revealing that solid, muscular pair of buns, more pear-shaped than Chris’ but somewhat more muscular as well. Elijah said, “Chris, you have to remove Travis’ boxers with your mouth.” Chris grinned and then nodded, “Ok. I can do that.” Travis stood up as Chris approached. Meanwhile, Tim took a seat on the sofa where Chris had been, between Jeremy and Elijah, to watch the show.
Chris got on his knees and grinned up at Travis who had a nervous semi-smile on his face. Chris began by licking at the wet spots in Travis’ boxers, and as he did, Travis’ hard cock escaped once again out of his fly. Chris gave it a few licks before taking Travis by the hips and turning him around to face the opposite direction. He then took the waistband in his mouth at the center of Travis’ back and valley at the top of his butt and pulled down, sliding his nose along Travis’ butt crack as he did. Travis’ cock twitched in response, sending more precum up through the tip of his cock. He slid them down until the waistband was under Travis’ buns and the front was pulling down at the base of his stiff cock, causing it to ache with need. Chris then turned Travis back toward him and grinned at the precum drooling from his cock. Chris first licked the precum from Travis’ cock, then took the waistband of his boxers in his mouth once more and pulled them over Travis’ stiff rod and down around his ankles. Jeremy glanced over at Tim and noticed he was slowly stroking his own stiff cock. When Chris began licking Travis’ cock from base to tip, Jeremy pushed Tim’s hand off his cock and replaced it with his own, then asked, “Are you ok with this?” Tim smiled and whispered, “Yeah.” Tim then pushed Elijah’s hand off his cock and then took both Jeremy’s and Elijah’s cocks and began stroking them as all three looked on at Chris putting his mouth over Travis’ cock and starting to slide his lips and tongue back and forth on it. Travis inhaled deeply and said, “Oh, fuck, that feels good.” Then he watched as each time Chris slid forward on his cock and applied suction, his dimples were revealed. Travis could only smile at the gorgeous face sucking his cock. The stroking happening on the sofa was getting much smoother as the precum flowed from all three cocks as they watched the show in front of them. Jeremy and Elijah smiled because the look on Travis’ face revealed how good their boyfriend, Chris, was making him feel. Tim was smiling as well, seeing his new boyfriend receiving a blowjob from Chris. He was also ogling Chris’ muscular apple butt and was wondering how it would feel to fuck it. It became obvious that Travis was ready to cum as his breathing was growing more ragged. Travis suddenly said, “I’m gonna cum!” Chris pulled of Travis’ cock, opened his mouth, and stuck out his tongue. The three on the sofa suddenly sprang up from the sofa and stood around Chris to get a closer look while they continued to stroke themselves. Then rope after rope of warm, creamy cum began splashing across Chris’ face and in his mouth. Travis groaned, “Oh, fuck!” Elijah said, “Fuckin’ hot!” Soon Chris’ face had multiple wads of cum slowly oozing from his cheeks and forehead. A long string dangled from his chin. As he started to get up, Elijah put his hand on his shoulder to stop him, “Hold on Chris, I’m next.” Elijah began cumming across Chris’ right cheek. Some across his nose and even some in his mouth. Tim stood to Chris’ left and began shooting his own swimmers across Chris’ left cheek. Travis then moved to the side and allowed Jeremy to step in front of Chris and began painting Chris’ face and hair with his own seed. As he was painting Chris’ face, Chris was painting Jeremy’s legs and feet with his own ropes of cum. As they finished, they were all laughing. There weren’t many areas of Chris’ face that didn’t have cum on it. Jeremy leaned down and kissed Chris, tasting the mixture of cum on his mouth. Then Travis did the same. Elijah followed, licking some of the cum from Chris’ face. Tim did as well. Then they took turns until all the cum was cleaned from Chris’ face. Tim then watched as Jeremy kissed his boyfriend, Travis, and swapped the cum in their mouths. Elijah then kissed Tim, followed by each of them kissing another until everyone had kissed everyone else. Tim then said, “That was so fire!” Chris said, “Yeah it was.” Jeremy noticed Travis’ cock still at attention and Tim was smiling at him. Then Jeremy looked at Elijah, who moved his eyes in the direction of his bedroom. Jeremy knew what Elijah wanted and picked up on what Tim and Travis wanted as well. Jeremy said, “Well, that was fun, but it’s getting late. I guess we should head to bed.” Chris grinned, and said, “At least to the bedrooms.” They all laughed, knowing sleep wasn’t what was on everyone’s minds.
It wasn’t long before Travis could be heard grunting and moaning and periodically yelling, “Fuck me!”, “Harder!, “Fuck!”. This was soon followed by the sound of Elijah moaning loudly with a stuffed mouth, and the sound of skin slapping skin as Jeremy fucked his ass and Chris fucked his mouth.
After showering, the throuple lay in bed. Elijah said, “That was really lit. I’m glad we did that. I thought Travis or Tim might be too shy to play, but they seemed like they had fun. I know I did.” Chris said, “Travis held onto my shoulders for the last half of the blowjob I gave him. He seemed like he was weak in the knees.” Jeremy said, “You should have seen the look on Travis’ face when everyone began painting your face. I don’t think his mouth closed the entire time. We introduced him to Bukkake.”
As Tim and Travis returned from getting their shower, they left the towels in the bathroom and walked naked back to Carl’s bedroom. As they crawled into bed, they kissed and Travis asked Tim, “Were you ok with Chris sucking my cock?” Tim smiled and said, “More than ok. Watching him suck your cock had me so hard, I had to stop Jeremy a couple times as he was jacking my cock. How was it for you?” Travis smiled and said, “It was so fire! Don’t get mad, but it was the best blowjob I ever had. He had his nose buried in my pubes a lot. I had to hold onto his shoulders, or I probably would have collapsed on top of him. My knees turned to rubber.” Tim said, “I’m not mad. Chris has more experience than me. I know he’s pretty good at it. I’ve been in that position, but I’ll get better at it.” Travis grinned and gave Tim another kiss, “We both will.” Travis then rolled onto his side and Tim moved against him as the big spoon.
End of Chapter 63
