First Time Gay Sex Stories

GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.

Speak Softly, but Carry a Big Stick

By Lee Obrien 16 Apr 2023

Quiet and shy Levi finds himself being bullied by a new kid at school. Levi has a secret weapon, once his bully pushes him too far, he decides to use it. The results are very satisfying for Levi.

9.2 (130) 5871 14 Min Comments

My college roommate is a masseur

By tylerjaygym 15 Apr 2023

Ethan is just starting at college, and it turns out his his new roommate gives massages! He wants to try it out.

9.1 (194) 8620 11 Min Comments

True Story First Time

By Tghtwhtbttm 15 Apr 2023

Two high school wrestlers have sex for the first time

9.3 (81) 4919 11 Min Comments

Boots made to get you hard

By Paul François 14 Apr 2023

The knee-high riding boot fetish of a virgin teenager boy gets him a penetrating initiation to gay sex from a wild instructor.

8.7 (22) 2627 7 Min Comments

First Experience Bottoming for Two Guys

By Late Night Charlie 13 Apr 2023

When I was 21 I lost my Butt Virginity to a person close to my age alot like myself that I met online. Years later, we reconnected and I wound up experiencing a gay 3 some as a bottom for 2 tops that were dating! It was all I imagined and more.

9.2 (72) 5845 10 Min Comments

Loads and Tow

By Phaggotry 12 Apr 2023

An ex-con turned repo man gets entangled with his older bosses and his housemates.

9.6 (10) 3881 99 Min Comments

On the Prowl (ch. 2)

By ClosetCase 9 Apr 2023

Justin, the young football player top, finds out he enjoys fucking older, middle aged guys by seducing his physics professor!

9.3 (56) 4283 12 Min Comments

The Piano Teacher

By Shy Stuart 9 Apr 2023

Stuart returns to his old school for piano lessons from his former music teacher. It's obvious that Stuart has a crush on the man but he's too shy and nervous to make the first move.

9.0 (33) 2711 6 Min Comments

The Rapper and His Wondrous Delights

By Phaggotry 9 Apr 2023

A metalworker reconnects with a bar patron turned rapper at one of his sex parties.

8.9 (9) 1579 21 Min Comments

Best Friends Push The Limits

By BiTexan37 8 Apr 2023

We both played on the baseball team and had become really good friends. Like good friends where we could share everything. Well, almost everything, so I thought until this one fateful day…

9.0 (226) 19556 5 Min Comments

From Best Friends to Fuck Buddies

By Paul François 7 Apr 2023

Two teenagers living in a remote community see how their friendship turns into sexual fun and ends up becoming love.

7.8 (40) 3764 6 Min Comments

Road Trip (ch. 2)

By Str8SensitiveGuy 6 Apr 2023

The same four friends reunite and take the same road trip to the Keys. This time it's Jay and Quinn's story. What led to Sean and Seb finding them together in bed?

9.1 (67) 2613 40 Min Comments

Why Him, of All People

By I. Dusk 4 Apr 2023

“Hi, daddy.” “Hi… please don’t call me daddy.” I was nervous as it was. He was eyeing me shamelessly, and I felt extremely uncomfortable. Nevertheless, I let him pull me in. Checking anxiously if anyone was out there seeing us. “And how would you like me to call you?” “I am Sam. What is your name?” “You can call me boy.”

9.4 (38) 4666 10 Min Comments

Daddy Mack

By Phaggotry 30 Mar 2023

A 19yo foolishly gets entangled with a 49yo and a trade school classmate.

9.2 (38) 8926 18 Min Comments

Life Begins at 30

By EdwardSpanks 27 Mar 2023

Fantasy becomes reality for a born again cocksucker!

8.3 (14) 1451 8 Min Comments

Thank God I'm Gay

By Paul François 24 Mar 2023

When a boy discovers that the pecs of a male bodybuilder excite him more than the boobs of a young women, he concludes that he must be gay.

8.4 (34) 2011 7 Min Comments

My Trial

By You’reslut 20 Mar 2023

This is my first time trying to write my first bathhouse experience, please give me advice if I mess up. TY

7.2 (23) 2270 2 Min Comments

The Summer of 1977

By Grant 19 Mar 2023

I was just a kid, eighteen and graduated from high school with the whole summer before me.

9.3 (133) 5442 59 Min Comments

Davy Wants Some Beer (ch. 2)

By Ryan Jones 16 Mar 2023

It was time for Mike to come over, for Davy and I to test out how we feel about the other one having sex with another person. When that finished it was time for Davy to experience his first fuck. Did he enjoy it? Read on and find out!

9.7 (29) 1519 28 Min Comments

First time gay sex (ch. 2)

By Dondee 16 Mar 2023

As we showered together after long lovemaking. We dried up and we both wrapped ourselves with towels. We went to chill in dining room and watch movie about a guy couple we grabbed some food and wine.

6.4 (9) 2105 5 Min Comments

Rael in the Bull Pen

By Phaggotry 10 Mar 2023

A eighteen-year-old virgin named Rael takes to cock during his weekend stint in jail.

9.3 (150) 23181 45 Min Comments

DeMario

By Phaggotry 9 Mar 2023

An eighteen-year-old boy loses it to his father's friend.

8.3 (42) 5517 9 Min Comments

Mardi Gras King Lends a Hand

By Habu 6 Mar 2023

New Orleans rent-boy being saved for auction gets used.

8.4 (26) 1596 16 Min Comments

Upstairs in Mom's Bedroom

By Phaggotry 4 Mar 2023

An eighteen year old loses his virginity to a girl he likes only to get a blowjob from his mom's straight male friend.

9.3 (47) 2978 13 Min Comments

A college golf player learns to cum handsfree (ch. 2)

By Jeremy Miller 25 Feb 2023

After losing his virginity yesterday and cumming handsfree three different times, Tyler was still hungry for more cock. Meanwhile, I couldn’t get him out of my head. I spent all day at work replaying the scene where his throbbing cock sprayed his boy juice all over my beard and hairy chest. Still so many options I wanted him (and me) to explore together.

9.5 (149) 10955 24 Min Comments

Pipe Blowing

By Phaggotry 23 Feb 2023

After the loss of his father, a visit out to California leads Karlos Steves to be a helpful apprentice to Mikey Bobo, a very handsome and talented mechanic that works for his Uncle Marv’s auto shop. After spending nearly every moment together on and off the clock during that hot summer things go from celebratory to intimate one night after a threesome with a busty taco stand waitress.

8.8 (20) 1647 16 Min Comments

Dick, Arse and Love Cocktail

By Paul François 22 Feb 2023

Two Canadian twins get an early start in boy-to-boy pleasures.

8.2 (23) 2992 7 Min Comments

Extra Practice with Dexter

By Lee Obrien 19 Feb 2023

I have been lusting after Dexter, the hot jock at my school, for our years. With only a couple weeks left of my high school years, I may never get the chance to be with him, or will I?

9.2 (201) 5998 15 Min Comments

Leading Up To It

By James and Me 19 Feb 2023

This details the events leading up to me loosing my virginity. Two straight guys fuck for the first time and then often

7.3 (21) 2215 3 Min Comments

Martin's Bitch

By Shy Stuart 18 Feb 2023

With no girls to fuck Martin turns his drunken attentions on me. I willingly, if a little nervously become his bitch for the night.

8.1 (45) 3893 7 Min Comments