First Time Gay Sex Stories

GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.

Lifegaurd

By djfmonkey 15 Feb 2023

Summer of my senior year I applied and got a State Lifeguard Job at the beach, the perfect Summer job, I got paired with a teammate that had me begin to think differently

9.3 (144) 7706 10 Min Comments

Peak of lust (ch. 4)

By Daniel Berasaluce 15 Feb 2023

Their lust goes on in a jacuzzi Devin has in his house. With total security, Gwyn asks Devin to fuck him, so they fuck each other and love also overflows.

7.5 (5) 329 6 Min Comments

Luke's Dad's Cockring

By Danny / Dane 8 Feb 2023

Luke and I had been friends with benefits in high school, sexting often and jerking off together in our free time. He was a year older so when I was a senior in school he had graduated and was going to the local community college. But that didn't stop us from sexting and jerking off and eventually fucking

9.2 (94) 5702 8 Min Comments

The Art of Taking It

By Phaggotry 7 Feb 2023

While trying to make arrangements online for a place to stay on vacation, a top gets topped by an older Puerto Rican papi named Ernesto.

8.9 (25) 2607 14 Min Comments

Deep Ass Fucked Muscle Pussy Virgins Recruits (ch. 39)

By Gazzaq 6 Feb 2023

Tariel and his father have and another sexual encounter. Then he meets the other Muscle Pussy Recruits. The next day he gets deflowered and discovers his father connection to the Karan goes much deeper than he thought.

9.2 (16) 1791 22 Min Comments

One Fucking Favor

By Phaggotry 27 Jan 2023

Mateo is a nineteen-year-old, loser baby daddy sent by his mother to deliver a cream pie to the new daddy neighbor, only to be on the receiving end of one.

8.8 (66) 6026 18 Min Comments

McDonalds and Atari with John

By G. Martin Blank 24 Jan 2023

It happened during Spring Break, a long time ago...

8.6 (43) 1995 4 Min Comments

First Time

By AgeOfDiscovery 20 Jan 2023

A friend I correspond with asked me to describe for him my first time getting fucked by another man. This is what I wrote to him. It’s a true story. If you have any comments or suggestions, I would like to hear them.

9.0 (43) 5585 4 Min Comments

Altar Boy

By djfmonkey 14 Jan 2023

Peter and I became altar boys in our church and we went a bit further than we should have, and we reconnected several years later.

9.3 (126) 7233 11 Min Comments

Frat House First Time

By Maikol 5 Jan 2023

White college boy gets laid for the first time in frat house

7.8 (33) 7172 7 Min Comments

The Boy From County Kilkenny (ch. 2)

By Greg Stevens 5 Jan 2023

I tossed and turned all night as guilt racked my brain trying to figure out what I was going to say to Declan. I felt terrible. I felt like I exploited him. Then my thoughts turned to fear; what if he said something to the Deacon or the other novitiates?

9.7 (57) 2020 10 Min Comments

Seeing How the Other Team Plays

By Midwest Horndog 2 Jan 2023

This is a one part story. Alex is a gay college student living in a dorm. He has an awkward conversation with a straight guy that lives on the same floor and gets surprised a few days later when the guy comes to his room to ask a few questions. A sudden lack of sex makes guys do strange things to satisfy their needs.

9.3 (101) 3801 18 Min Comments

Answered an Ad (ch. 2)

By djfmonkey 1 Jan 2023

A well known 40 Year old Professional closeted guy, try's out an Ad for Sex and eventually gets coaxed into it. The last part of a short two part story.

9.5 (118) 2846 8 Min Comments

Loosing it in High School

By Midgabear72 1 Jan 2023

Well this is a story about how I had my real first man on man Experience.

8.1 (30) 3798 13 Min Comments

The Full Experience (ch. 6)

By CMNM_anon 31 Dec 2022

The morning after Chase and Corey's first encounter.

9.4 (21) 1183 9 Min Comments

The new delivery boy

By Midgabear72 31 Dec 2022

This was a true story that happened to me many years ago with a guy that was in his 20's and I was in my 40's. I hope you like what I have written

8.4 (38) 3525 10 Min Comments

Little streams for Joel (ch. 2)

By Daniel Berasaluce 29 Dec 2022

Joel trains David now in footjobs and both men are getting more into each other.

8.8 (11) 954 11 Min Comments

First Big Score

By Habu 26 Dec 2022

Jim sells his first time to please his college basketball coach.

8.7 (62) 4525 21 Min Comments

Mike is my new Neighbor

By djfmonkey 22 Dec 2022

A older guy meets his new neighbor Mike, and tried to set him up with his daughter, only one problem, the new neighbor is gay.

9.3 (171) 6337 16 Min Comments

A Dream Cum True

By gay_sex7171 20 Dec 2022

I'm a 20-year-old gay guy. But no one knows it. Except for my best friend Jack, whom I have known nearly my whole life. I really fancy him; he's so hot with his giant muscles and beautiful abs. I've fantasized about him nearly every time I've jerked off. But nothing will ever happen between us. Or so I thought...

8.9 (102) 8756 3 Min Comments

Another straight friend tries some cock

By DDK 11 Dec 2022

A straight friend comes to visit and he wants to explore his bi side, who am I to say no

7.7 (38) 6318 4 Min Comments

My Crush (ch. 2)

By djfmonkey 11 Dec 2022

OK, Your comments and emails were heard, due to overwhelming demand here is a second part to “MY Crush” Follow the continuing First Time experience of Drew and Dan.

9.5 (152) 2640 9 Min Comments

My 1st time fucked: The high school football player

By Jeremy Miller 10 Dec 2022

I had just graduated from high school. I’d be heading to college in a few weeks, and I was still a virgin. Losing my virginity before getting to campus had turned into an obsession. A trip to Greece at our neighbors’ summer home would be my best chance to score with their son, who was on our high school football team.

9.1 (215) 15185 29 Min Comments

First lick

By lickme 5 Dec 2022

A young naive heterosexual guy being led towards a whole new appreciation for cock

8.6 (91) 7747 6 Min Comments

Tim uses me

By Fun bottom 5 Dec 2022

Tim uses me however he wants

8.2 (60) 5238 3 Min Comments

It Had To Be One of Us (ch. 2)

By RJC 4 Dec 2022

Two friends; one sucks the other. A few weeks pass and everything changes.

9.3 (19) 1636 8 Min Comments

How it all started

By Jason 3 Dec 2022

A true story of my first time and secret gay antics

8.4 (33) 3826 7 Min Comments

Unwillingly Outed

By djfmonkey 3 Dec 2022

A High school student assigned a project was teamed up with a class bully Ben, results in an interesting encounter.

9.3 (145) 4716 9 Min Comments

My friend is need, is what I desired

By Lukenstein 1 Dec 2022

This is how I got what I fantasised about for a long time by taking advantage of his disadvantaged situation

8.0 (27) 1643 9 Min Comments

Virile Boob Ecstasy

By Paul François 30 Nov 2022

Son of a gymnast trainer, Paul discovers muscle worshipping and man-to-man pleasures with the help of a bodybuilder.

8.2 (16) 2015 6 Min Comments