First Time Gay Sex Stories

GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.

Complete Opposites

By Str8SensitiveGuy 1 May 2024

The star of the football team and a nerd are paired together as college roommates. They become unlikely friends and eventually more. The sports star gets abducted by rivals and the nerd comes to his rescue.

9.3 (155) 5236 50 Min Comments

Drugs make you do crazy things in college

By Finaltouch 28 Apr 2024

I consider myself straight, but a random night in college my roommate and I were seduced by two gay friends.

9.2 (156) 10559 6 Min Comments

Cherry Picking in the Vineyard

By Habu 22 Apr 2024

Gay Egyptian Londoner takes son to Cyprus for initiation.

9.3 (61) 4324 20 Min Comments

Straight Boy Mansion

By Shadow123 21 Apr 2024

Brian is a straight male in desperate need for money, when a gay millionaire bets him, "One hour of sex with me, if you don't like it, I'll give you $50k." Brian is confident in his sexuality and could really use the money, so he takes the bet. This'll be the easiest money he'll ever make, right?

9.2 (56) 5932 19 Min Comments

First Love

By ganymede 20 Apr 2024

After the Homecoming football game, Gary and Todd engage in another type of game. The two boys explore each other's bodies and form a bond that will last for years.

9.3 (87) 4443 16 Min Comments

Streets to Sheets

By Pothos Scout 19 Apr 2024

A frightened young twink, who finds himself recently alone after being kicked out of his house, reflects on his first time with a charming redneck jock boy from his small hometown.

9.3 (128) 11119 13 Min Comments

Well-Cut Hairstylist

By Paul François 19 Apr 2024

A client walks in a hair salon for just a mustache trim. He ends up with a public hair trim and a unique experience in man-to-man pleasures.

9.0 (37) 2559 5 Min Comments

Slippery Slope

By Habu 16 Apr 2024

Craig lets ambition sink him into the world of male prostitution.

9.7 (37) 4186 49 Min Comments

Strange Library Encounter

By Shadow123 16 Apr 2024

A nerd in college hasn't had success getting laid by any girls. One day, a guy comes up to him and boldly states that he wants to have sex with him. A chance for free and easy sex, but with a man. Will he accept his offer?

9.2 (77) 4727 13 Min Comments

Employee of the month

By Shadow123 15 Apr 2024

Jerry is caught for a fireable offense in the office. But as the new hot young guy in the office, his boss gives him one last chance to keep his job. How far will he go to avoid being fired.

9.0 (81) 4942 9 Min Comments

Breeding Pretty Boys

By Prettyboy 14 Apr 2024

Jerry loves a virign and breeding pretty boys. He meets Justin and connects with him so eventually he initiates Justin into gay sex. Justin is bred and becomes a gorgeous bottom bitch that loves cock up his ass.

8.3 (59) 4360 4 Min Comments

A Canadian Cowboy's Nirvana

By Paul François 7 Apr 2024

An older cowboy has a big ass. A younger cowboy has a big dick. They are meant to saddle up. Welcome to Homo on the Range where one saves a horse by riding a cowboy.

8.6 (40) 3719 7 Min Comments

My Buddy's Big Blond Balls (ch. 2)

By Brandon 4 Apr 2024

Part 2. My buddy goes back to playing video games without putting his clothes back on. As I watch him I get brave and give him a blow job. A first for both of us.

8.8 (46) 3126 2 Min Comments

Pat's Bar, Last Call

By LaidBackCoolGuy 4 Apr 2024

When asked by a mutual friend, Johnny arrives as last call is shouted out at the bar, to get Erik home safely. These two men, Erik a widower and Johnny married with kids, who don't know each other well, get a bit carried away in the moment.

9.5 (44) 2907 18 Min Comments

April Fools

By JChristian 2 Apr 2024

An April Fools joke goes a little too far with two straight young men.

9.2 (211) 9786 12 Min Comments

1980s Prom Tale

By Str8SensitiveGuy 29 Mar 2024

It's some time in the 80s. Two friends slowly and secretly become more than friends. When another friend figures out their secret, he surprises the closeted couple with a special private prom night for just them. Unplanned, the night ends in a John Hughes moment as the two boys dance and kiss center stage with the whole senior class watching. Lots of 80s music and fashion.

9.4 (49) 1482 34 Min Comments

The Farm Boy's Mammoth Dick

By Paul François 26 Mar 2024

An English cucumber or a corn on the cob up your ass is nothing compared to what Brad can offer Hector to reach the utmost divine sexual ecstasy he is longing for.

8.2 (90) 5824 4 Min Comments

From pain in the ass to butt extasy

By Paul François 23 Mar 2024

George discovers that being pounded hard and deep is fucking intoxicating. Maxime, the fucker, finds out that there are sometimes barriers to a love story.

7.9 (27) 2415 5 Min Comments

Me and Mr Donovan

By Polarbear58 16 Mar 2024

Big dicked student fucks teacher on theatre trip

9.2 (102) 8248 28 Min Comments

The Construction Site (ch. 2)

By Brandon 14 Mar 2024

Liam finds out how he’s going to repay Noah for his blow job. They both strip down and Noah tells Liam what to do.

8.9 (64) 3287 2 Min Comments

Mr. Meyer Makes a Man of Me (ch. 3)

By AtlantisGuy 12 Mar 2024

Months of confused feelings towards Mr. Meyer were finally coming into focus, and I was on my way towards finding the greatest release of my life.

9.5 (151) 7666 24 Min Comments

Mitch's adventures (ch. 2)

By Drugh Bowers 6 Mar 2024

A flashback to Mitch's first time with another man

9.3 (26) 2578 6 Min Comments

First time sex

By Tony 29 Feb 2024

My first time with actual sex

6.9 (40) 6180 4 Min Comments

I Use To Be Straight

By Gray Rose 24 Feb 2024

Corey should have seen it coming a mile away. Gibril was never shy with his flirting. He knew Corey was straight but that didn't stop him. Corey knew Gibril wanted him. So why didn't he stop hanging with the one guy he knew could seduce him?

9.2 (182) 10669 12 Min Comments

Sexual Awakenings (ch. 2)

By 243907 23 Feb 2024

A story of sexual awakening in the 50s/60s in the UK

8.8 (29) 1495 3 Min Comments

My First Time Gay

By NCBottom 18 Feb 2024

My first time hooking up with another guy and giving up control

8.6 (39) 6446 4 Min Comments

First Time Bottom

By MountainMankind 15 Feb 2024

Orally experienced guy bottoms for the first time.

8.6 (43) 6416 3 Min Comments

Chuck Buddies

By Prettyboy 12 Feb 2024

Paul and Jack are good friends in high school. They both love wearing high top Converse sneaks. They start to experiment with sex and Paul fucks Jack for the first time.

8.4 (49) 4184 3 Min Comments

Best Mates Fuck

By Prikz 11 Feb 2024

I was shocked when my best mate told me he'd fucked men but that was just the beginning .

9.2 (194) 9124 11 Min Comments

Florida Panther

By Grant 11 Feb 2024

It was so lonely on the reservation, that Billy didn't know how to endure it. Then he opened up to someone and everything changed.

9.3 (161) 3862 41 Min Comments