It finally happened - but was it worth it?
By Jack Writes 31 Jul 2025
This is a true story – please don’t judge too hard, I was young and still coming to terms with my new life
First Time Gay Sex Stories
GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.
The Wedding Guest (ch. 3)
By Jay Taylor Johnson 31 Jul 2025
After a recent breakup threw a wrench in his plans, Drew ends up crashing with his old friend Marcus - and Marcus's new boyfriend - for a destination wedding.
Private stripper (ch. 5)
By Daniel Berasaluce 28 Jul 2025
Ivor has so much gotten into Dennis that now he tries everything and also wanna live with him after now.
The Cherry Breeding Festival
By Josh Prim 28 Jul 2025
In order to earn some badly needed money, Mark has his dad enter him into a contest.
The Night I Lost My Virginity
By StoriesByTroy 23 Jul 2025
How I Lost My Virginity to my long term boyfriend on my 18th Birthday
Tongue Goes In First
By Paul François 23 Jul 2025
High school football players offer a variety of oral sex experiences to a classmate who has a hungry tongue.
Raw Freshmeat Rush in the Barn (ch. 2)
By teenhungtop 20 Jul 2025
Archer stepped into view, stark naked, his sculpted body a vision of raw power, muscles gleaming in the dim light like polished bronze. His eight-inch cock stood proud, bobbing slightly, a beacon of heat that drew Jack’s gaze like a moth to flame.
Ron and Evan (ch. 15)
By Derek D 20 Jul 2025
Ron and Evan pack up to return home from their camping trip. On their way, they encounter an unexpected scene. Once they are back in their neighborhood, Ron notices Evan acting a little strange after talking to his girlfriend, Jenny.
Revealed (ch. 2)
By thebearcub 19 Jul 2025
Our Twinks Story continues, how will his encounter go with the mystery man at school? how does he handle it...
The Rumor
By johnnnyboy 17 Jul 2025
A friends to lovers story with some kinky stuff mixed in. My fave.
Advertisement - Please visit our sponsor!
Summer with Uncle Samuel
By Rex 15 Jul 2025
After completing my freshman year at college I moved to the country to help my uncle run his Christmas tree farm. Uncle Sam lost his wife two years ago due to a car accident. That summer I learned a great deal about my sexuality and had a great teacher.
Toby to cocksucker (ch. 4)
By Metullus 14 Jul 2025
Cocksucker has got a real reputation at the adult all-male College where he's the groundsman. He gets visits from horny freshmen who need some relief from the academic year.
Catholic Boy
By ShyHottie 13 Jul 2025
Tristan is a young, catholic 21 year old that is trying to go to door to door to raise money for a charity. He ends up knocking on the wrong door.
Love Is Blind
By Borehamwoodman 11 Jul 2025
Richard is blind and needs a companion. Steve got the job and had a summer ahead of him, being the eyes for the young man.
Greece (ch. 3)
By BiTexan37 10 Jul 2025
Day two with Alex and Nico.
Zach - Anya's Boyfriend, Shane
By BurnAfterReading17 10 Jul 2025
Heteroflexible college freshman agrees to a m/f/m threesome and gets more than he bargained for.
My first time
By Tim 8 Jul 2025
First time with an older man
My Virgin Husband: Honeymoon Night
By DanXWrites 6 Jul 2025
It’s a romantic, passionate, and deeply filthy first night between Liam and his husband Corey after three long years of waiting for sex. And now, Corey’s not holding back. Liam’s about to learn exactly what it means to be claimed.
The First Time
By Noah Cummings 25 Jun 2025
Alone in the city for the first time, nineteen-year-old Noah is hungry for more than just freedom. A visit to a secretive sex club and a bold online hookup lead to an unforgettable night of submission, pain, pleasure, and awakening. Raw, honest, and deeply erotic—The First Time is where innocence ends and desire takes over.
First Time being a Bottom
By Bottomonce99 19 Jun 2025
Hey it’s Mike again this time I’m gonna write about my First Time being a Bottom to a man
Advertisement - Please visit our sponsor!
Best Friend First Time (ch. 2)
By Steel 11 Jun 2025
After a night of pleasure - Steel and Josh take it to the next level in Love and Lust.
To New Experiences (ch. 6)
By Topofthehill 11 Jun 2025
Nathan from the grocery store comes over to Deans Place and things get Interesting.
Truth or Dare
By Clark Wayne 7 Jun 2025
During a game of Truth of Dare, two buddies are dared to kiss each other. The kiss stirs an awakening in both guys.
Amster-Damn Hot (ch. 4)
By The Men We Crave 5 Jun 2025
Two perpetually horny college bros head to Amsterdam chasing girls and wild nights—but a boozy, drug-fueled evening takes an unexpected turn when frustration and heat explode into a night of raw, passionate intimacy between them. What starts as a ridiculous sex-comedy detour becomes a messy, electric awakening neither of them saw coming.
The Rugby Club
By 243907 3 Jun 2025
Finding my sexuality in the rugby club
My First Trucker
By James Stone 29 May 2025
In the late 1970's, at 18 years of age I already knew I liked men. Not boys, men, masculine, but not buff. Just the typical blue-collar worker. Living along a highway I would see semi-truck drivers going by regularly. There was also a truck stop about ½ mile from my house where I would go to get gas for my motorcycle.
My Sub Journey
By ASubbyStory 24 May 2025
My first gay experience with a much older male that wasn't very fun but opened a door I later explore.
Back To School
By Theo 17 May 2025
Carl went back to his old high school as a teacher and rekindled a friendship. The friendship with the older man turned into much more.
Art's New Life
By AngryGayGoose 11 May 2025
Arthur is set up on a blind date by his friend, Ellie. Things only go up for him in a world of new experiences when he meets the man she found for him.
Jesse’s Encounters with Older Men (ch. 2)
By ajay 11 May 2025
Jesse is 24 (21 in this chapter), shy, a little soft around the edges, and hopelessly obsessed with older men. A drunken night out leads to a chance encounter with his former principal — his first time turns into something slow, deep, and unforgettable.
About our first time sex stories
GayDemon Story Library has been online since 1999 and is currently a topmost destination for reading the best gay erotica first time stories. With an extensive collection of gay first time experiences described by authors from imagination or reality, our story library is completely at your disposal, free to read and download. Any short story or novel you can read here is the creation of an individual author. Therefore, we kindly ask that you respect the writer's copyright and not repost the stories you like without their consent. Consider leaving a vote and a comment when you enjoy these gay sex stories, as it's a way to show authors your appreciation of their hard work.