Jeremy was an exceedingly handsome, tall, lean, well-defined, smooth, blond twunk who was a year ahead of us in graduate school. My boyfriend, Paul, and I began speculating about Jeremy’s sexual orientation, agreed that the man was “sex-on-legs” and “drop-dead gorgeous,” and that he would be a lot of fun to have in our bed. We noted that he didn’t have any girlfriends, never talked about women, and agreed that the significant attention which he paid to refining his physique was causing our gaydars to ping. One evening after marathon sex, when Paul mentioned that he had never been fucked in the ass by two guys at the same time, I suggested that Jeremy might be able to help us with that. I pointed out that, from the way Jeremy filled the front of his gym shorts, it was likely that he had a large slab of tube steak with which to help me fill Paul’s hole. Paul got excited at that prospect, and so from that point forward we looked for ways to bring Jeremy into our lair so that we could feast on his beauty.
The opportunity presented itself a couple of months later when, in a class on Church Administration, the three of us were grouped together and assigned a joint project. We were tasked with devising a new organizational structure for a church, and so we got together for dinner one night to work on that project. Jeremy brought over some BBQ he’d picked up someplace, while Paul and I provided the sides and the drinks … our plan was to also provide the dessert!
After eating and chatting for a while about school and the social goings-on among several fellow students, we settled down to do our work together. As we finished up the organizational chart and were defining the various positions and the kinds of people we would need for each, Paul excused himself to “go to the bathroom.” I was sitting on the floor next to Jeremy, leaning up against the couch, and we had the butcher paper spread out before us on the floor. Jeremy was looking at the chart and was preoccupied with counting the number of people we would need for populating each committee when Paul came back from the bathroom. I put my arm around Jeremy’s shoulders, said his name, and he turned to look at me. I said something like: “I think Paul has a better suggestion for populating things” and I remember Jeremy turned to look up at Paul and noticed, for the first time that, that Paul was standing on the other side of the chart without a stitch of clothing on ... and was sporting a hard cock that was already dribbling pre-cum.
Jeremy looked up at Paul, then looked at me, then back to Paul. After a moment, he turned back to me and said: “is this what I think it is?” I smiled and, without a word, kissed him. Jeremy was passive for a moment in the midst of the kiss, then leaned into it with me and put an arm around me to finish the kiss. We then both got up and approach Paul from either side, Paul turning to Jeremy as Jeremy leaned down, gathered Paul’s naked body into his arms, and kissed him square on the lips. I came up behind Paul, took hold of his ass in my hands, and cuddled in to nuzzle his neck.
In less than three minutes we were back in our bedroom stripping Jeremy's clothes off and exploring every inch of his amazingly sexy body. He was as beautiful as we both had dreamed, and his cock was mounting up huge with each beat of his heart. I took ahold of his dick and compared it to my own raging hard-on: I’m 7.5 inches long and 6 inches in circumference; Jeremy was, incredibly, at least 8 inches long (perhaps longer, I didn't use a tape measure) and about 5.5 inches in circumference – truly, a gorgeous penis. We pushed Jeremy down onto the bed and then Paul cuddled down around Jeremy’s waist and started sucking on his dick while I settled beside him, we kissed, and I caressed his naked chest and abs. He was, indeed, both very nicely built and very smooth. I traced the outline of the muscles under his pale skin and mentioned to him that I liked how very lean he was. “Yeah, not much extra meat on me” he said. Paul pulled his mouth off Jeremy’s cock to say: “this is the meat I’m most interested in.” I used my mouth to kiss and lick my way across his chest, tracing the line of his sexy pecs all the way around. I tweaked his nipples with my teeth, and ran my tongue across his clavicle, then down his neck to his Adam's apple. I even ran my tongue down the center of his chest to his washboard abs, where I paid attention to his sexy belly button. Throughout all of this, and while Paul was sicking his dick, Jeremy was wiggling and giggling and moaning from our touch as he ran his hands through my hair, along my shoulders, and up and down my hairy chest.
This went on for a while. I was so excited that my cock was aching, throbbing, tight, heavy, hot, and purple, and was also flowing copious amounts of precum; Paul, for his own part, was so horny that he was trembling with excited anticipation at what we both hoped was about to follow. After making out with Jeremy for a dozen or so minutes, we proceeded to share him what Paul wanted, what I wanted, too, and that we were going to focus first on Paul’s need to be poked with two cocks at once. Jeremy admitted that he’d never done anything like that before, but that he found the thought of double penetrating Paul exciting and was looking forward to trying it; for my part, I assured him that I had done it before, many times, and that it would be a wonderful gift to Paul.
Jeremy lay down on his back and Paul straddled his waist; I crouched in behind him and applied lube to Paul’s ass and Jeremy’s cock before helping to guide Jeremy’s veiny, long, blood engorged penis to Paul’s puckered hole. Jeremy’s cockhead was pressed tightly against Paul’s sphincter, and I knelt there and held Paul’s ass cheeks wide apart and watched as my boyfriend slid down such a beautiful pole, stopping to bob up and down only a couple of times as his ass consumed Jeremy’s dick. Since Jeremy’s cock was longer than mine, though not as thick, I suspected that he would be able to punch through Paul’s inner hole. Sure enough, Paul came to a stop with some of Jeremy’s cock still outside his ass. I put my arms around him from behind and whispered into his ear “take him all the way inside you … bear down hard, dear.” Paul did, and then gasped as he slid the rest of the way down until Jeremy’s balls mashed against his ass. Once Jeremy was all the way inside, Paul began to ride him just like he road me … long strokes up, then back down, then up again, then back down, and I settled back to stroke my own cock while I watched the show. It was an amazing sight, and even though I wouldn’t have believed it possible, I found myself growing even hornier by the stroke. In just a couple of minutes Jeremy warned that he was getting close to cumming, so Paul slowed to a stop and, while still crammed with cock, looked over his shoulder at me and said “fill ‘er up.”
I grinned at him, knelt on the bed behind him, and pressed my cock up against his hole. Jeremy repeated his warning, so I reached down and eased his dick out of Paul’s butt, replacing it with my own. Paul’s ass had been well-plowed, and now was gaping open. I fucked him for a couple of minutes, getting off on the amazing feel of an ass having been made ready for me. It had been a while since I’d done anything like this, and it was wonderful. Paul was kissing Jeremy, and I leaned over and watched them make out while I slowly fucked in and out of my lover’s wonderful ass. At one point, when Paul rested his head down on Jeremy’s shoulder, Jeremy stretched his neck up and I leaned down further and we kissed. My weight was heavy on Paul’s back, my cock was heavy in Paul’s ass, and I could also feel Jeremy’s dick pressing up under my own balls, hot and hard and ready. And so, just as I began to feel the pressure to cum mounting behind my dick, I slowed to a stop, pulled out, and then helped Jeremy to reinsert his cock up inside Paul.
Telling them both to hold still, I placed my cock head against Paul’s dick-crammed hole. Jeremy said that he was ready, and Paul mumbled agreement while resting atop of Jeremy, his head on Jeremy’s strong shoulder and his lips nuzzling Jeremy’s neck. I pushed inward. It was tight and incredibly hot. Jeremy’s cock was throbbing with excitement as his heart raced, and he gasped in surprise as I slid up inside Paul, my cock resting on top of his, both of us tightly gripped by Paul’s twitching chute. Meanwhile, Paul’s mouth was wide open, the sound of moaning ecstasy was rumbling out of his throat, and his eyes had rolled back in his head. I held still all the way inside him with my cock's head pressed against the back of Paul’s rectum along side Jeremy’s; I relished the feeling of my balls resting on Jeremy’s, and my cock mashed against his’ while surrounded by the tight tissues of my lover’s rectum. I’d missed this feeling and the sense of power that my position held. Paul had entirely given himself over to us both, and Jeremy was also under my complete control as I leaned over, made full body contact with Paul’s back, and reached past him to place my hands on Jeremy’s strong biceps and shoulders … effectively pinning them together down to the bed. Slowly, oh so very slowly, I began fucking while repeatedly instructing Jeremy to hold perfectly still and continue to hold Paul to him. I continued to slowly fuck, filled with lust at the power I had, yet at the same time realizing that there wasn’t any way that I would be able to last as long as I wanted. After a couple minutes of slow piston-action, the air filled with the smell of man-sweat, the sound of Paul’s nearly incoherent babble, and Jeremy’s gasping for breath as he fought to keep from blowing his own load, I suddenly discovered that I had to slow down even more until I barely moved … I was pulling out most of the way and then pushing all the way back in at the pace of about 1 stroke per 5 seconds. I had straightened up, placing my hands on Paul’s ass and gazing down at my cock and Jeremy’s meat underneath it, and was touched by Paul’s supreme trust in me and his utter vulnerability to us both. I could feel my cock tremble in Paul’s ass, dancing on the edge of orgasm, and I suddenly realized that I was about to cum; with a final surge of passion, I began pumping deeply and with vigor just before I felt that freight train go roaring down my back and my cock swelled one last time as I unloaded a massive volley of cum way up inside Paul and all over Jeremy’s dick. The heat of my cum and the friction of my pumping must have sent Jeremy over the top because, while I was still pulsing my nut, Jeremy’s cock suddenly erupted underneath mine with an orgasm of such intensity that I could feel its gut-wrenching strength with each pulse along the length of my dick. Surge after surge of hot cum permeated the area around our dicks as, together, we populated the inside of Paul’s hungry rectum and colon with what seemed like a quart of cum. Both our cocks were spasming with our orgasms; with that heavy pressure on his prostate, the walls of his rectum, and his sigmoid, it all must have been too much for Paul because he suddenly groaned, lifted himself up on his arms, and we all looked between them as Paul’s cock, nestled in the muscular groove of Jeremy’s abs, began to pump out a thick stream of cum while his hole spasmed around our cocks. It was fucking HOT.
Collapsed in a pile of exhaustion, we all cuddled together and rested, the cum drying on our bodies. At one point, I know that Paul dozed off because he was lightly snoring while facing me, his head nestled against my chest and with Jeremy spooned in behind him. Jeremy and I lay there, side by side, with Paul between us, and we smiled at each other. We occasionally kissed and whispered a few things to each other, but mostly we just enjoyed the respite, the quiet, and the intimacy of post-orgasm bliss. I think all three of us dozed some, but after about an hour and a half Paul woke up and went to the bathroom, leaving Jeremy and me to cuddle in each others arms for several minutes; he then came back with some gatorade, and then the three of us sat in a circle on the bed and talked for a long time; Jeremy asked how we knew about him being gay, and Paul and I shared our frustrations about trying to get him into our bed for just this reason. After a while, Paul and I both noticed that Jeremy was getting hard again. I reached down, took ahold of his cock, and told him that we would have to do something about it. Paul, the greedy little slut, said “yeah, I need you in me again.” But I put out a hand on Jeremy’s chest and countered, “No. I need you. I’ve not been fucked in ages.”
Within a few minutes I was on my back, Jeremy had my legs over his shoulders, and he was pounding into me with steady, long, powerful strokes. It felt wonderful to lay there, gently caress his sexy torso, and be plowed by a strong top. Paul was getting off watching Jeremy fuck me, and I could feel his touch as he ran his fingers along Jeremy’s shaft and around my hole. Having already cum, Jeremy was able to fuck me for quite a while … long enough for me to enjoy him on my back and then roll over onto my stomach and relish being deeply taken from behind. In this position, Jeremy’s dick was not only long enough to hit the bottom of my rectum, he was actually punching hard against my second hole. I asked him to fuck into my colon and that made him so excited that, without hesitating, he pushed as hard as he could and – POP – he penetrated my junction and surged at least a half-inch into my sigmoid colon. A nuclear bomb went off in my head, I yelped and felt myself experience a very strong internal orgasm … the first of its kind that I’d felt in years. I didn’t ejaculate; my cock was still very hard, but my toes curled and rasping gasps escaped by throat as I arched my back and lifted myself up on my hands in the midst of the experience. Thankfully, Jeremy paused only for a moment; he then pulled back and began pumping long and steady strokes in and out of my ass, pounding deeply until he blew his second wad far up inside me.
At this point, we took a shower break, put on underwear, ate the leftovers from our dinner, finished our class project, and then talked late into the night about a broad range of subjects. By about 4 am I was still horny, and so was Paul, so the three of us got back into bed for a “third draining” of our sexy Jeremy. We got Jeremy hard, then Paul mounted him again, engulfing his incredible cock all the way to its base. Then, I bunched up a pillow under Jeremy’s hips, spread his legs wide and tipped them back; I pulled his cheeks apart, exposing his hole, applied some lube to it and my cock, and then began to work first one and then several fingers into him. Jeremy mentioned that he had never been fucked, and I told him that it would be ok. I pressed my cock head against his tiny hole and waited. The tension was supreme, but I knew that he wouldn’t be able to keep me out for long. Paul was still facing away from me, straddling Jeremy's waist, working Jeremy's dick with his ass. He would grip and then release Jeremy’s cock again and again in a rhythmic motion that I knew to be mesmerizing; Paul could make me cum just by doing that around my cock, and I didn’t even have to move because it felt so incredible. I watched that for a moment, knowing how good it feels, while looking at my own dick pressing in tightly, and bouncing back and forth ever so slightly, against Jeremy’s hole. The distraction of Paul repeatedly clenching his ass must have been enough to do the trick because, suddenly, Jeremy’s tiny pucker spasmed open and my cock penetrated to its widest point just behind its head. Jeremy gasped out a yelp of sudden shock and pain, but Paul leaned all the way down and planted his mouth on Jeremy’s, stifling the cry with a passionate kiss.
“It’s okay, baby,” whispered Paul. “You can take his cock.” All Jeremy moaned was “O God!” Meanwhile I waited, feeling Jeremy’s pulse through his sphincter as my cock began to swell even more from the excitement. Thus far, apart from an internal orgasm, I’d cum only once about four hours ago, so I had a big wad to offload into Jeremy’s guts. I backed off slightly, the head of my dick anchoring me inside his anus, and then I leaned heavily forward; and, with a sudden SNAP, my cock plowed all the way down into Jeremy’s love-tunnel, where I hit bottom just as the base of my cock was being clinched by his ass. With this, and as Jeremy cried out with a combination of pain and pleasure, Paul began riding up and down on Jeremy’s cock again. It was incredible to feel and to watch. Each time I slid down into Jeremy, Paul would pull up until just the head of Jeremy’s dick was in his ass; then, as I pulled back out of Jeremy, Paul would settle back down, taking all of Jeremy’s tool up his chute. This rhythmic pattern began slowly, but within a minute we were going strong and steady and in synch with each other.
Since Jeremy had already blown two loads, I figured that he would be able to hold out for a very long time, and I was right. Besides, we were all in our 20s and at the peak of our sexual prime. Nevertheless, before too long I was sweating buckets and enjoying myself immensely as I began to feel the urge to cum building behind my cock; as for Paul, he was trebling with excitement and exhaustion as he grew closer to blowing his own load. Then, after maybe twelve or fifteen minutes of this relentless, non-stop action – fucking and being fucked – Jeremy cried out with a loud, husky voice that he was about to cum. My fucking ground to a stop, way up inside him, as Jeremy’s hole spasmed and contracted tightly around my cock and he unloaded into Paul.
I waited as his orgasm subsided and then Paul stood up, pulling off Jeremy’s spent cock. He stepped forward and then knelt back down to feed Jeremy his bloated, heavy, cum-dribbling dick. Meanwhile, I continued to kneel there, with Jeremy’s legs over my shoulders, as I slowly started to piston into him again. While Jeremy was being throat-fucked by Paul, I continued fucking his ass, pushing in deeply and holding still for a moment to flex and swell my dick. It felt amazing to have the head of my cock pressing against the back end of his rectum, and I reveled in making this gorgeous man take me like this. I only wished that I had been long enough to penetrate his second hole … but I wasn’t. Jeremy was a tall man (taller than me, at 6'3"), and my experience had long been that shorter and smaller guys often had shallower rectums that allowed my 7.5 inches to penetrate all the way through the sigmoid junction. As it was, my dick was completely filling Jeremy’s rectum: I could feel the tissues on the walls of his chute pressing all around the sides of my cock so that, as I moved, I felt the tight tugging of his deep hole.
At this point, Paul unloaded his cum into Jeremy’s mouth and then pulled off and out of my way. I leaned forward, placing my hands on Jeremy’s chest, and looking down into his face. “Are you ready?” Jeremy never answered me. His mouth was open, I could see Paul’s cum on his tongue, and he had a look of supreme lust on his face as I continued to fuck him. I started to slow down, pacing myself toward my orgasm, when I suddenly felt Jeremy’s cock between my stomach and his abs begin to stiffen up again. This was amazing: Jeremy was quickly building back toward a fourth orgasm! I said as much, and he tossed his head from side to side and gasped out a passionate “yes.” I fucked him slowly, allowing him to enjoy the sensation of first my head and then my shaft sliding across his sensitized prostate. I could feel his entire rectum responding to my cock, tightening and then releasing with each thrust; and, then, Jeremy experienced an internal prostate orgasm just as his cock shot a small amount of cum out over his abs. With his hole gripping my cock so tightly, all I could do was press inward and hold myself there, feeling the back of his rectum starting to give way against the pressure of my cock. In a split second, just as I felt the tip of my dick starting to penetrate Jeremy's junction, I cut loose with a heavy nut deep inside his amazing ass.
The rest of the night was spent in cuddling and talking. We put the finishing touches on our project (we got an A) and we talked about engineering another 3-way a couple of nights later, which was somewhat more relaxed than the first time. Over the course of the last few months of the semester, Jeremy and I serviced Paul’s ass together on multiple occasions; Jeremy fucked me as well, and I him. I tried again to reach his sigmoid colon, but no matter what position we put him in, the best I could do was press just the very tip of my cock into the junction. We still tried, though, and it was fun trying. On one occasion we even arranged for Paul to ride me while Jeremy fucked my ass, reverse of the way we had done it the first night. It was wild, and I managed to stay hard until Jeremy unloaded inside me; afterward, he stayed in me, his cock starting to soften ever so slightly, while Paul road me to my own mind-bending orgasm and then he blew all over my chest. It was incredible.
After Jeremy graduated and was gone from our lives, Paul told me how much he had enjoyed watching me get fucked; I told him that he could always fuck me, if he wanted, and even though he thanked me for the offer he repeated that he just couldn’t do it … it “didn’t feel right” for him to fuck me. We talked about that some more over the subsequent couple of months, and at one point he admitted to me that the thought of fucking another guy had an appeal for him, but that he wasn’t sure that he could do it with me. Even so, Paul repeatedly talked about how much fun that time with Jeremy had been, how much he really enjoyed being double fucked, and about how watching me get fucked was such a huge turn on for him. He also said that the experience had taught him that I really did enjoy getting fucked, too, and that he wanted me to have that same pleasure as I gave him nearly every day. That conversation led to our hooking up with a much younger, very cute, very buff undergraduate student for several steamy 3-ways about which I’ll share in a future story.
I’m still in contact with Jeremy. Because he is clergy in a denomination that isn’t affirming, he has had to stay in the closet throughout his ministry. However, over the years he’s had a couple of lovers and multiple fuck buddies, and for the most part he’s been very happy. From the photos, time has been very kind to him … he still looks very fit and, while his hair has gone grey, he is very distinguished.
