My First Daddy
Visit My First Daddy

My First Daddy

myfirstdaddy.com 17 Feb 2025

My First Daddy offers young men in their 20s & 30s playing with older dads & grandpas ranging from 50 to 70 years old. These studs love playing with men twice & three times their age & they really appreciate the sexual experience these daddies bring to the bedroom. 383 streaming, mobile-compatible videos with 2 monthly updates, lots of daddy-boy sex.

Overall Score: 75 / 100

$29.95 / month
Get instant access!

In This Review

My First Daddy Review

My First Daddy pairs up younger guys in their 20s through their 40s with older men in their 50s, 60s, and 70s. There's even one man they call the 80-year-old miracle, and Don Rodrigo is actually 82 and fucks two different guys. Right on, grandpa! This site is produced by the creators of Older 4 Me, which has been filming sexy older men for over 25 years. It's been just under two years since we last looked inside, so let's head back and catch up.

Most of the scenes on My First Daddy are filmed in Buenos Aires, Argentina. The admirers are a mix of Latin and American guys ranging from their early twenties into their forties. Some have slender to athletic bodies while others are a little more muscled or thicker, and there are a few chubby guys in the mix. They're often smooth or sporting just a bit of fur on their chests, but others are quite hairy. I found some to be fairly cute with dark hair and eyes, not to mention uncut cocks, but others are more average. Most of the pairings feature daddies who are twice or three times the age of their partners, and the younger guys seem to appreciate the experience an older man brings to the bedroom. 

Among some of the releases are 40-something men playing with daddies in their sixties. So if you like watching older men sucking and fucking, you'll find some of that here, too.  The site has also filmed a handful of times in the US with men like Jake Marshall, Jake Cruise, Christian Matthews, Tony Da Rimma, and Brad Kalvo, and I find in these cases that the age spread wasn't as great between the daddy and his admirer.

The older men come in all shapes and sizes. Some have solid, muscular bodies or are in fairly good shape, others are stocky or a little soft around the middle, and some have big bellies. I saw a lot of hairy chests and beards, and you can expect salt and pepper or silver hair, as well as quite few bald men. Many are uncut, so you can expect plenty of foreskin. And many of the men are single-name performers, so they're amateurs as opposed to gay porn regulars, although having said that, many of these men appear time and again in this studio's videos and across their network of sites, so while they're unknowns in the larger gay porn arena, they're familiar faces in the mature man niche.

Most of the action here is hardcore with plenty of blowjobs, ass fucking, and rimming, but there are also a few daddies jerking off in solos in the earlier scenes from 2009 and 2010. Most of the sessions feature an older man with a younger guy, but 17 videos featured threesomes with two daddies taking on one younger stud, or in some lucky cases, a daddy gets serviced by two younger guys at the same time. The site began filming when condoms were still used in most gay porn productions, but they started filming bareback in 2010, then more regularly after 2013. Men are still free to use condoms today if they prefer, but most don't, and there are 228 bareback scenes.

Sometimes the guys get right down to business, but some of the videos have fun ways of getting the men into the action. In the cases where there's dialogue, the men mostly speak Spanish, and sometimes there are subtitles, but not always. Still, these aren't long-winded storylines, and it's not hard to figure out what's happening.

Before I talk about the videos, it's important to cover the set-up of MyFirstDaddy. The site's memberships give you unlimited streaming videos but don't include downloads. For those, you need to buy packages of credits, and members get a 20% discount. It's also possible to buy packages of credits to stream or download videos à la carte. You can use the monthly membership and credits in tandem. This site has also introduced Daddy Sticks, which allow you to pick six or nine scenes from the network and have them mailed to you on a memory stick. These cost $39.95 or $49.95 each. Videos cost five to eight credits per download, depending on the age. Buying videos one at a time can get expensive, so I suggest opting for the streaming membership and keeping track of the videos you'd like to own; then you can buy the needed credits before your membership expires.

My First Daddy offers 383 semi-exclusive, streaming videos in MP4 format. These days the videos come in two resolutions; an HD and SD versions, and the player resizes the videos to fit your device. The highest quality versions fare best and also look best in full-screen mode. The older scenes are offered in two speeds, and while they're still enjoyable, they're not as crisp and sometimes experience interlacing. Good news is that the site and videos are mobile compatible. If you opt to use credits and download some of the videos, you'll get MP4s sized at 1920x1080 or 1280x720, depending on the age. The newest scenes are good quality, and as with the streaming vids, the older ones are enjoyable but lack sharpness and clarity.

Most videos come with a picture set. The pics are digital stills, the newer sized at 1200x1807 or 1200x675 at good quality and the older are smaller at 600x800. Each gallery has around six pictures with the men clothed posing nude before the action; the rest are taken during the filming of the scene. The pictures display in a slider underneath the video that shows five to eight large thumbnails at a time, then you use the forward arrows to continue through the set; no slideshow feature is available. There are 40 to 70 pictures for each video and you can save the pictures individually or grab the whole set in a zip download file.

MyFirstDaddy updates twice a month with a new video. The updates are usually added on the 5th and 20th of the month, but I found some updates added on the 19th or 21st, so it's not always consistent. Suffice it to say that new scene are added twice a month.

In the Filters section at the top of the Scenes page, you can sort the videos by date added or popularity, you can also browse a number of categories like uncut cocks, threeways, daddy tops younger, and more. Categories are found on the navbar, but you'll also find a selection of them under the video player on each episode's page. The performers' names are clickable so you can find more of your favorites, and all of the performers can be found in the Models section on the navigation bar.

My First Daddy has two unchecked offers on the billing page, so you should double check to make sure they are still unchecked when you join. The site provides a profile page for most models, and these include stats, but they're not consistent so while some have age, weight, height, dick size, cut / uncut, and their sexual position, others only have a couple of items. None state the model's home country; they're simply listed as Latino. A number of the videos here have been used to launch a new site called My Step Fucker, but if you've never been a member of either site, this won't be an issue.

If you like intergenerational gay sex, My First Daddy has a good offering of 383 exclusive, mobile-compatible videos. Most feature guys in their 20s and 30s sucking and fucking daddies in their 50s, 60s and 70s, but there are some 40-60 pairings, too. I like that the site mixes things up so that the younger guys aren't always bottoming - I enjoy watching them also fucking the daddies and grandpas. The chemistry is genuine and exciting to watch; the men, especially the younger guys, aren't just phoning it in for a paycheck, they are really enjoying themselves. The site updates twice a month, and My First Daddy members get unlimited streaming so they can watch as much as they like.

Visit My First Daddy Now

Pros

  • Mostly exclusive content
  • Good variety of older/younger pairings
  • Good chemistry between the men
  • Daddies in their 40s through 70s
  • Site and videos are mobile compatible

Cons

  • Members must pay extra for downloads
  • Not every video has a picture gallery
  • Not every man has a full profile
  • 2 unchecked offers on billing page

Changes Since Last Review

  • Site has added 38 videos in 18 months
  • Download credits are now lower in price

Videos

Videos are available for streaming, with an option to purchase downloads.

383 semi-exclusive streaming, mobile-compatible videos in MP4 format. Player resizes vids to fit your screen, 2 or 3 speeds at average to good quality. Downloads cost extra.

Pictures

320+ picture sets. Newer pics are good quality digital stills sized 1200x1806 or 1200x675, older pics are smaller. Pics can be saved individually, zip files available, no slideshows.

Membership Prices

  • Monthly: $29.95 (recurring)
  • Monthly: $34.95 (non-recurring)
  • Quarterly: $49.95 (non-recurring)
  • Half Year: $79.95 (non-recurring)
  • Yearly: $139.00 (non-recurring)
  • Credits: $14.99 to $89.95

Get Full Access Now!

Free Preview Videos

Get Instant Access to All Videos!

Members Area Screenshots

Themes & Keywords

Why You Can Trust Our Review

Online since 1999, GayDemon is your trusted, expert guide to membership sites. Our team of seasoned editors has decades of combined experience in the gay porn industry, providing objective & critical reviews with your interests in mind. We pride ourselves on being thorough, honest, & transparent in every review we publish. The review of My First Daddy details what you can expect as a member if you choose to subscribe, providing an accurate overview as of 17 Feb 2025. Please note that websites evolve, and we cannot guarantee that the content, prices, or features will be exactly the same when you visit https://www.myfirstdaddy.com/.

At GayDemon, we maintain full editorial independence, and while we may earn a commission if you purchase through links on our site, this has no impact on our opinions or review quality. Our goal is to always provide honest, unbiased assessments to help you make informed decisions about MyFirstDaddy & other membership sites. If you have any questions, feel free to contact us or leave a comment.