Guy Selector
guyselector.com 4 Oct 2024
GuySelector offers horny gay porn stars from guys in their 20s to daddies in their 40s in hardcore suck and fuck action with a twist - you can also choose the order of the action. Stepfather/stepson sex, profession/student, room mate sex, and more. 49 streaming, mobile compatible videos & site updates twice a month. Lots of oral and anal sex.
Overall Score: 62 / 100
In This Review
Guy Selector Review
Guy Selector is a recent site from the folks who bring us MEN.com, only this site has a twist. The tour says the site is "an interactive porn site that puts you in the shoes of the stud" and is "the best porn game". The performers here range from guys with average bodies to muscle hunks, and ages range from twenties to lots of mature men in their thirties and forties. Most of the performers are pretty masculine; I didn't see any twinks here, although you will find Andy Adler, who has a boyish look to him. There are some familiar faces here like versatile Dylan Creamer, handsome daddy Rico Raunch, Black muscle hunk Donovan Cox, to name a few, and if you like gay porn star Scott DeMarco, he appears in over 20 videos here. You'll also find Black daddy Aaron Trainer, sexy Luca d'Amore, and Latin stud Rikk York.
So how does this work? Each episode lets you either watch the full video or you can select START GAME. After a brief intro to set the scene, you'll get two choices, then another two, and these let you choose things like "Jerk Him Off", "Sex Toys" "Foot Play" and so on. There's no way to skip ahead to the fucking, and sometimes a choice may lead to one of the guys shooting his load, and you have to start over if you want to get to the fucking. Once you get there, you get your choice of three positions, and at the end of the fucking, you get your choice of two cumshot options - facial or internal.
There are some fun scenarios. Professor Aaron Trainer's student, Vincent Grey, who hasn't been showing up for class and is in danger of flunking. He tries to seduce the professor to get a passing grade, and when the professor says he could lose his job, the student pulls off his clothes and turns on the heat. The student ends up bottoming, and Professor Trainer is very vocal as he fucks his ass. There are next door neighbor and roommate scenarios, and some fauxcest sessions, too. In one scene, stepson Scott DeMarco admits to stepfather Rick Kelson that he's been kicked out of college, and after some fatherly advice, the guys lie naked in bed. Scott strokes the silver-haired, bearded daddy's cock, his stepfather sucks his cock, and finally daddy bottoms for his stepson. A lot of the action is shot POV after the initial set-ups, where we do see both guys.
Guy Selector offers 49 streaming videos in MP4 format available in resolutions from 320p all the way up to 4K (2160p). The videos are good quality, although I'd only recommend the two smallest resolutions for those on small devices, and if you want to enlarge to full screen on larger monitors, I'd suggest one of the two highest quality versions, which enlarge well with no issues. Downloads aren't included with your membership, but I believe you can purchase them separately.
When it comes to updates, the episodes are dated, and it seems that GuySelector is adding two videos each month.
Let's talk about downsides. There's a pre-selected offer near the top of the billing page; to opt out, click "Yes, add..." and select "No thanks". The trial membership gives unspecified, limited access, and it recurs at $10 more per month than the regular monthly membership. When logging in, you'll land on a page full of ads; be sure not to tick the unticked box or you'll be joined to an additional membership site. Also on another of this company's sites, I've seen that box checked, so be sure to look for that. By joining, you automatically agree to receive commercial emails. The model index is huge, but most of the models don't appear in any videos, and the model info sections for the guys that I viewed simply say N/A on each line. Each video player has a gallery tab, but if you click it, it leads to a blank page.
My last complaint here is what GuySelector promises versus what it delivers. Each video or the game version starts by telling you that you can choose your own stud, but in reality, each video stars two performers that can't be changed. Regarding the game versions of the videos, it's more like a "choose your own adventure" book than a game - there's no play or interaction as they say - the game versions let you pick the order of clips of the full video after the initial clip - you can get two choices, like footjob or blowjob, romantic getaway, or jerk him off, but you can't skip ahead to the fucking, and you can't choose who tops, or any action outside the defined parameters.
Guy Selector offers horny gay porn stars including plenty of sexy daddies, guys in their twenties and thirties, and Black studs in hot gay sex including plenty of ass fingering, sucking, fucking and handjob action. You can stream the 49 exclusive, mobile compatible videos as full scenes or use the game option like a "choose your own adventure" to watch the clips in the order of your choice, which can be fun. Dates show this site updating twice a month, and fans of gay porn star Scott DeMarco will love it here as he appears in about half the videos. There are some titillating themes like room mate sex, stepson/stepfather fucking, neighbors sucking cock, professor/student sex and more oral and anal action.
Pros
- Exclusive content
- Hot porn stars, lots of daddies
- Fun and dirty scenarios
- Site and videos are mobile compatible
- Pick the order of the action
Cons
- Downloads not included for members
- No actual game play or interaction
- Model profiles not filled in
- Most models don't have any videos
Videos
Videos are available for streaming, with an option to purchase downloads.
49 streaming, mobile-compatible videos in MP4 format in resolutions up to 4K at good to very good quality. Downloads require additional purchase.
Pictures
No pictures.
Site Issues
Pre-selected offer near top of billing page. Trial membership gives limited access and recurs at $10 more than monthly membership. By joining, you agree to receive commercial emails. Full-page ad when logging in.
Membership Prices
Trial membership only gives you limited access. There are pre-checked options on signup page. If left checked, you will automatically be subscribed to another site.
- Trial: $1.00 (recurring at 39.99 per month)
- Monthly: $29.99 (recurring)
- Quarterly: $49.99 (recurring)
- Yearly: $119.99 (recurring)
Members Area Screenshots
Why You Can Trust Our Review
Online since 1999, GayDemon is your trusted, expert guide to membership sites. Our team of seasoned editors has decades of combined experience in the gay porn industry, providing objective & critical reviews with your interests in mind. We pride ourselves on being thorough, honest, & transparent in every review we publish. The review of Guy Selector details what you can expect as a member if you choose to subscribe, providing an accurate overview as of 4 Oct 2024. Please note that websites evolve, and we cannot guarantee that the content, prices, or features will be exactly the same when you visit https://www.guyselector.com.
At GayDemon, we maintain full editorial independence, and while we may earn a commission if you purchase through links on our site, this has no impact on our opinions or review quality. Our goal is to always provide honest, unbiased assessments to help you make informed decisions about Guy Selector & other membership sites. If you have any questions, feel free to contact us or leave a comment.